DEBITO.ORG
Arudou Debito/Dave Aldwinckle's Home Page

New ebooks by ARUDOU Debito

  • Book IN APPROPRIATE: A novel of culture, kidnapping, and revenge in modern Japan
  • TPR on why the passage of HR 121, “Comfort Women” Resolution, is not a bad thing

    Posted by Dr. ARUDOU, Debito on August 10th, 2007

    Hi Blog. I listened last night to yet another excellent Trans Pacific Radio essay from Garrett DeOrio on HR 121 (the “Comfort Women” Resolution), and why its passage by the US House of Representatives on July 30, 2007, is not a bad thing.

    What I didn’t know was all the “nicely, nicely” that went into it, and even then the Japan Lobby in Washington came down on it hard. But in his view this “meddling” just made matters worse for them in terms of PR. Excerpt follows:

    ======================
    The negative view, that the US is meddling in the affairs of a sovereign Japan, is even more porous than the positive view.

    For starters, as I mentioned above, the US House, through this Resolution, is not advocating, much less taking any action against Japan. There is nothing in H.R. 121 that suggests that even the House thinks Japan should take it seriously. Constituents of a member of the US House of Representatives, Mike Honda of California, made a complaint and Representative Honda took that complaint to the appropriate Congressional committee, in this case the House Committee on Foreign Affairs, chaired by Representative Tom Lantos, also of California.

    The propriety of the Committee’s actions in this case should not be in doubt. Since when have governments or governmental agencies been concerned only with their own actions or incidents that occur on their own soil? Should the House Committee on Foreign Affairs be taken to task for condemning what is now going on in Darfur? Few outside of the Sudanese government would say so.

    But when it comes to now peaceful Japan, such actions, even in the form of flaccid nudges, become “meddling.”

    There is no meddling. No agent of any part of the US government is trying to change any internal policy in Japan. The closest thing to this would be the resolution that states that Japan “should educate current and future generations about this horrible crime while following the recommendations of the international community with respect to the ‘comfort women’.” This, though, is not telling Japan how to educate its children or plan its school curricula.

    Meddling requires at least some hint of action.

    The first two times H.R. 121 was set to face a vote in the Foreign Affairs Committee, it was taken off the agenda due to pressure from the six-figure-a-month Japan lobby in Washington. Pressure was put on members of Congress and diplomatic strings were pulled to silence the issue.

    Members of the Government of Japan took out a full-page ad in the Washington Post demanding that the Resolution not be passed and Ryozo Kato, Japan’s Ambassador to the United States, threatened strained or damaged relations should the Resolution pass.

    That, dear readers, is meddling.
    ======================

    This is what the blogosphere can do best–present an alternative viewpoint from a dedicated researcher, and amplify it with good writing (unscathed from the again “nicely, nicely” tendencies of corporate journalism beholden to advertisers).

    Have a read (or better yet, a listen; Garrett is a good reader) at http://www.transpacificradio.com/2007/08/02/the-comfort-women-resolution-hr-121-passed-why-thats-not-bad/

    Well done again, Garrett. Debito in Sapporo

    One Response to “TPR on why the passage of HR 121, “Comfort Women” Resolution, is not a bad thing”

    1. Trans-Pacific Radio » TPR’s First Anniversary (太平洋横断放送 一周年): One year of politics, news, business, opinion, OTR, and more from Tokyo, Japan in podcasts :: Independent Podcasts from Tokyo, Japan - Japanese News, Politics, Says:

      […] Last, but far from least, we’d like to heartily thank Debito Arudou.  Not only has he recorded three interviews, a Seijigiri, and an edition of TPR News with us, he’s also offered us encouragement and said nice stuff about us on his blog.  (Here, too.) […]

    Leave a Reply