Books, eBooks, and more from Dr. Debito Arudou (click on icon):
UPDATES ON TWITTER: arudoudebito
DEBITO.ORG PODCASTS on iTunes, subscribe free
“LIKE” US on Facebook at http://www.facebook.com/debitoorg
If you like what you read and discuss on Debito.org, please consider helping us stop hackers and defray maintenance costs with a little donation via my webhoster:
All donations go towards website costs only. Thanks for your support!
Thanks to readers for putting this in the Top Ten most-read JT articles for two days in a row! — Debito
STOP NORMALIZING SUMO AS AN ETHNO-SPORT
Foreign coverage of the new Yokozuna Kisenosato is embedding racism
By Debito Arudou
Just Be Cause Column 105 for the Japan Times Community Page
Monday, February 20, 2017
I know that by now this is old news (blame press holidays and timely Trump articles), but congratulations to Kisenosato last month for ascending to yokozuna, sumo wrestling’s highest rank. After all your efforts, well done.
So what does JBC have to say about it? Nothing to diminish that achievement, of course. But let’s consider how the event echoed overseas. Here are some headlines from prominent news outlets:
BBC: “Japan gets first sumo champion in 19 years”
Washington Post: “After 19 long years, Japan has a grand champion of sumo once again.”
New York Times: “For the first time in years, Japan boasts a sumo grand champion.”
The Guardian: “Kisenosato becomes Japan’s first homegrown sumo champion in 19 years.”
Even our own JT: “Kisenosato becomes first Japanese-born yokozuna in almost two decades.”
Hmm. At least three of those headlines make it seem like Japan hasn’t had a Japanese yokozuna – or any yokozuna – for nearly two decades.
That’s false. We’ve had five yokozuna (Musashimaru, Asashoryu, Hakuho, Harumafuji, and Kakuryu) since 1998.
Unless they’re referring to the fact that the last four champions have been Mongolian, not Japanese. But that means they don’t count?
Then what about Musashimaru? He’s a naturalized Japanese, and was one (as the Japan Times duly noted) when he became yokozuna in 1999.
So he’s not counted because he’s not a “real” Japanese? Apparently. That’s why the JT and Guardian slipped in qualifiers like “homegrown” and “Japan-born”. As if that matters.
It shouldn’t. Except to racists.
And it matters in Japan because of the embedded racism of the sport…
Read the rest at
Do you like what you read on Debito.org? Want to help keep the archive active and support Debito.org’s activities? Please consider donating a little something (More details here.). Or visit one of our advertisers
11 comments on “Japan Times JUST BE CAUSE column 105: “Media, stop normalizing sumo as an ethno-sport”, Monday, Feb 20, 2017”
Yeah, the story that the international media should have run was;
“Japanese xenophobia denies identity of every sumo champion for last 19 years.”
Kind of puts a whole different take on it, doesn’t it?
The article seems like a re-emergence of cultural hypocrisy over discourse of racism in Japan. It’s not something new, and I guess some of us (including myself) are getting so sick and tired of iconic idiocracy that can be carved out from arguments of “Wajin privilege or Japanese-ness.(In other words, arguments are so flawed that people have little difficulty in identifying the key players for perpetrating racist discourse.) One thing I found out about the discourse of racism is that many critics and western pundits left out the foreign subjects or agents as part of key players in shaping/reshaping deliberation on race discourse, just because they are outside the soil. That has been bothering me for a long time. I was even pissed at some point when some people in the blog accused me of being pseudo-occidentalist by providing foreign examples to interconnect with Japanese context for critical venues.
Because such choice among many pundits to portray Japanese society as product of cultural endogeny strikes the false perception of uniqueness that smacks cynicism at us on the head: Japanese social problems cannot be fixed or alleviated because they are product of cultural endogeny that blocks any ideas coming from outside its national soil. So, why not leave it as it is and let it fixed by Japanese?” (Do these line strike you?) This type of thinking is exactly what mirrors the apathetic attitude of people (both Japanese and non-Japanese) who say sarcastically, “if you don’t like Japan, then, why don’t you go back to your home country?”
I don’t disagree with people saying Japan is a unique democratic society. But that doesn’t mean that they are unparalleled or impenetrable because it is unique in so many ways. I think it’s right time to shift our focus–or expand our scope to key players outside the Japanese soil for critiquing discourse of race/gender/culture in Japanese society.
The guys of Freakonomics had a chapter dedicated to match fixing in Sumo. Kisenosato could be there because they need him to be there. One last rally for the dying sport of Sumo.
This is priceless.
Japan zoo culls 57 monkeys carrying ‘invasive’ genes
And this is why sumo doesn’t deserve a free pass;
“Go back to Mongolia”, how classy. Are they gonna scream at every NJ Olympian who beats a Japanese too?
Given that sumo has seen a string of scandals in recent years, I would be surprised if the new ‘ethnically Japanese’ sumo champion was promoted to Yokozuna just because the racist old codgers running sumo can’t stomach Mongolia born top-dogs in their sport!
The guy’s just lost 3 times in a row, whilst the Mongolia-born Japanese are coming off their 9th straight wins!
I’m also curious how media will respond to his buddy Takayasu, who is a half-Japanese and a half-Pilipino, when he gets promoted to ozeki next month.
I thought that the promotion was premature – the very arbitrary “or equivalent” rule coming into play. (The same kind of decision that prevented Konishiki getting the yokozuna promotion. That particular decision proved correct, however)
Having said that, Kisenosato did win the next tournament, which would have sealed that yokozuna promotion anyway.
BUT I have an issue with the sudden rise in popularity of the sport following the promotion of a Wajin simply because he is a Wajin and the media hype pushing that angle. (In Japan if you want something to become popular, just get the media to tell people that it’s popular)
Kisenosato has pulled out of the tournament claiming ‘injuries’.
The Mongolia born sumo aren’t pulling out. And they aren’t losing. This ‘pure’ Japanese sumo is a weak fake promoted too easily as a panacea for deflated national pride.
So, how’s that great Japanese first Japanese Yokozuna doing?
Promoted because he was Japanese, not because he’s a top class wrestler. Funny how all the media have nothing to say about him all of a sudden.
Said it before, sumo is currently engaged in a racist effort to ‘purge’ the sport of Mongolian ‘influence’ (i.e. Mongolian born Yokozuna who could retire and become stable-masters and Sumo association big-wigs).