Books, eBooks, and more from Debito Arudou, Ph.D. (click on icon):
UPDATES ON TWITTER: arudoudebito
DEBITO.ORG PODCASTS on iTunes, subscribe free
“LIKE” US on Facebook at http://www.facebook.com/debitoorg
Hi Blog. Debito.org Reader Sven Kramer sends this update to a petition he launched against the Japanese Government’s Re-Entry Ban on visa-carrying NJ Residents, who were barred (unlike Japanese citizens) on an unscientific supposition that foreigners are more likely to carry Covid. And this racist policy caused great hardship to many.
As of September 1, 2020, thanks in part to some impressive international and domestic protests, the Japanese Government as amended this ban. Now it’s no longer a blanket ban. Instead, there are extra hoops, including an exit permission and an unreasonable expectation of test results abroad (when domestic tests can reveal the same symptoms) that are only applied to foreigners, same as before.
Moreover, Japanese citizens are still treated as less likely to have disease, in spite of all the science that shows that Covid does not recognize differences in nationality. Consider this new report from the Japan Times, excerpting (courtesy of W):
[…] Even so, entry procedures will differ for those abroad who are seeking re-entry and residents in Japan who are planning to leave… [sparking concerns that even legal residents may face deportation due to unclear and strict requirements that differ from those applied to residents with Japanese passports].
Non-Japanese who left Japan by the end of August will need to contact the nearest Japanese Embassy or diplomatic office to acquire a letter confirming they have valid visas and are allowed to return. Those who left as early as April 3 or after travel restrictions were imposed on their destinations, and were denied the right to return as their circumstances did not qualify for exceptional treatment, will also be able to obtain such certificates.
People who are planning to leave Japan after Sept.1 are required to give the Immigration Services Agency detailed plans on their itinerary and will be allowed to travel as soon as they receive a document confirming the request has been accepted. They will not need to apply for additional documents from an embassy or consular office.
The ISA has warned, however, that they may suspend document issuance for applicants seeking re-entry if testing capacity at airports is insufficient to handle all foreign travelers. Japan was planning to boost its testing capacity to 10,000 per day at the major international airports ー Haneda, Narita and Kansai.
The ISA is set to disclose an email address where requests for re-entry can be sent on its website at noon on Tuesday. Travelers will need to input their residence card number, nationality, and other details as stated on their passport, as well as details of the trip, including destination, planned departure and re-entry dates and information on which airports the traveler will use.
Residents planning to leave between Tuesday and Sunday are requested to share the date of their return during the departure procedure at the airport.
However, starting from September, all non-Japanese, including permanent residents, will be required to undergo specific tests for COVID-19 in accordance with Japan’s guidelines prior to their leaving for Japan. The government has warned that not complying may result in denied entry.
The Immigration Services Agency has claimed the strict conditions are aimed at limiting the spread of the virus in Japan. In contrast, however, Japanese nationals coming from abroad are not required to undergo pre-entry tests for COVID-19…
Full article at:https://www.japantimes.co.jp/?post_type=news&p=2739610
Sven’s amended petition is below, forwarding with permission. Feel free to sign it. Debito Arudou, Ph.D.
About the lifting of the reentry ban against legal non-Japanese residents of Japan since September 1
SEP 1, 2020 —
About the lifting of the reentry ban against legal non-Japanese residents of Japan since September 1, 2020, and the future of this petition
Since September 1, 2020, all legal non-Japanese residents of Japan can leave and reenter the country. This is a very important and uplifting development. With this most recent easing of restrictions, almost all points of this petition were met.
However, one vital point of this petition (equal treatment of all legal residents at the border regardless of nationality) is still not fulfilled. Only non-Japanese residents have to apply for a Receipt for Request of Re-entry at the Immigration Services Agency before departing from Japan. No explanation in given why this is necessary and why a valid residence card and the normal reentry permit is not enough. Furthermore, only non-Japanese residents (except for diplomats and special permanent residents) have to take a PCR test abroad within 72 hours before the departure for Japan. However, this requirement can nobody meet who stays in a country which does not test people without symptoms or does not deliver the results on time. And anyway, the PCR test at the Japanese port of entry should suffice. Residents of Japan have Japanese health insurance. This is why they are entitled to treatment in Japan if the PCR test at the Japanese airport should turn out to be positive.
Requesting negative PCR tests before going to Japan should be limited to non-Japanese who want to newly enter Japan. This requirement should not be bestowed upon legal residents, who have their livelihoods already in Japan. Therefore, this petition is going to continue until the requirement of PCR tests abroad is abolished for all legal residents of Japan regardless of nationality.
The official documents in question by the Ministry of Justice of Japan:
“Regarding denial of landing to prevent the spread of COVID-19”: http://www.moj.go.jp/content/001327574.pdf
“Additional Epidemic Prevention and Control Measures for the Entry of Re-entry of Foreign Nationals”: http://www.moj.go.jp/content/001327575.pdf
Do you like what you read on Debito.org? Want to help keep the archive active and support Debito.org’s activities? Please consider donating a little something. More details here. Or if you prefer something less complicated, just click on an advertisement below.
33 comments on “Updated petition against Japan Foreign Resident Re-Entry Ban: Still discriminatory: Requires extra hurdles for all NJ only, including extra GOJ permissions and overseas Covid tests”
Japan being run by all racist old Japanese men is the biggest hurdle for our society to overcome. No vision, no insight, no drive to try to be less racist… old man culture of Japan must go!
Thank you for blogging about this issue. Just for transparency, the initial Japanese version of my update – especially the second half of paragraph #2 – had some cringeworthy language errors, which I’ve corrected now.
I live, work and pay taxes in Japan. My life is here now and has been that way for the past 7 years and being treated like a tourist is simply unacceptable.
Japan is a great great place to live.
As long as you have no troubles it is one of the best.
During this crisis, I feel very sad to be flagged by my residency place government as an “undesirable” and see families ripped appart because foreigners -regardless of their contribution to society- are not considered more than “long term tourists”.
Is this the message that the world people and world economy is supposed to receive: japan is OK to not follow the rules they agreed ?
It is a strong message for the world economy: do not go to Japan if you await fairness ? I hope I am proven wrong.
Sven, Thank you for your diligence. The petition has been signed and forwarded to about 90 people (50% Japanese who agree with us).
@Racist Japanese: Not sure about your name or your post but from the looks of how the current “election” is being held to replace Abe you are 100% correct (limiting who can vote in this election to those who will essentially tow the “party line”).
The sad thing is this will hurt Japan in the long run and nearly all Japanese people I have spoke to think this immigration policy is 100% wrong, especially when the consider it separates families.
I believe people’s perspectives are changing in Japan but the government is not changing and is not willing to change with the people. It is like China here more and more.
spot on with the China comparison; I was already mentally making it after your second paragraph.
I just wish the Japanese public would have the balls to stop voting for LDP and their spin of “safe pair of hands”.
A vote for LDP is also a vote for nukes on faultlines….. Thats all that needs to be said.
Also Abenomics, what a joke. Look at this graph here
love how 1998 and 2015-18 are essentially the same little w shape of up and down into the red. Except 2015 is worse.
or this one, hardly a glowing vindication either
So, why vote LDP? I mean, really, Japanese people, why?
Not to hijack the thread by going on about empty-suit-Shinzo, but I read an interesting article last week that said his only major ‘achievement’ was a long period of stability when what he promised (and Japan needs!) is structural change/reform.
He was too weak to implement his own plan.
BTW, that second link you posted was strangely calming. Japan is only 4.22% of the global economy, I guess I don’t have to worry about Japan’s debt crisis crashing the global economy.
Abe’s legacy is this;
He juiced the nikkei 225 by devaluing the ¥. Those companies aren’t suddenly worth twice as much as they were 8 years ago, the ¥ is just worth less. And with the BOJ continuing to use money from bonds issued against presumed future tax revenue to invest on the stock market and keep stock values from sagging under the weight of reality, Abe has left his successors no exit strategy that doesn’t crash the market and dump on the Japanese economy.
I said it elsewhere but I have seen graphs of Japan’s GDP which are strikingly similar throughout. In 1998 there was a little rise fall rise fall pattern in the black and then back into the red, and exactly the same patterin in 2018.
Long term, indistinguishable. Except that there were a couple of big drops under Abe, the obvious one being due to Covid, which I suppose is “shoganai”. A bit like how voters blamed the DPJ for 3.11 and the earthquake tsunami and voted for the LDP in droves, was that “shoganai” too?
Anyway, so much for Abenomics.
“stability”? More like stagnation and power elite consolidation.
“Nostalgic for the 80s? Find having to make a political choice “mendokusai”? Like familiarity? Then leave it the Erai Hito from famous elite families! Vote LDP. Everything will stay the same, frozen in time while Gaikoku moves on.”
Well, this is the thing, isn’t it?
Japan seems to have never heard ‘If you want things to stay the same, things have to change’ and insists on refusing change and watching things get worse.
As for your other point, the media is pushing how ‘vigorous’ and healthy Suga is (compared to Abe) because he does ‘ 100 sit-ups everyday’.
Meaningless. I’d rather know how many languages he speaks, and how many books he reads a month.
Just what Japan needs; another old man with no experience outside of the same bubble all the old men before him were in.
Jim, funny that you’d mention the question of how many languages he speaks, or how many books he reads. I’d be inclined to agree at first, but allow me to share an anecdote about that sort of thing.
Just yesterday, I discovered some teaching materials one of my superiors at work made. He’s a trilingual (Japanese, English, and French) who was born in Zimbabwe and attended international school as a child. Of course, he’s a Wajin.
In the above-mentioned materials, he decided to take up racism as a topic, and surprise, surprise, he exclusively discussed America and Europe, even going as far as to dig up some random Wajin living in Europe during WW2 who apparently opposed the Nazis. Not even so much as a word about racism in our country, though.
I sent him an e-mail pointing this out, stating it was odd that he would completely fail to even mention problems in our own country, and that discussing racism only in the context of America and Europe ran the risk of giving children the impression that racism was only a problem in “gaikoku.”
He clearly got butthurt about what I said and ultimately defended his actions by declaring that teaching children about Japan’s racism problem might invite criticism against our company. He also explicitly stated that he objects to the word “Wajin,” despite being unable to suggest an alternative, and even criticized Dr. Arudou. In a nutshell, all the usual racist attitudes common to so many Wajin.
In summary, unfortunately it would seem that neither foreign language skills nor experience living abroad do much to correct racist attitudes.
Personally, the most open-minded Wajin I meet can only speak Japanese and have never been out of Japan.
– What was his criticism of me?
Dr. Arudō, thanks for your question.
His empty, intellectually dishonest criticism was just the kind of garbage one would expect. Despite declaring to me that he has “above-average awareness of Japan’s racism problem,” he also admitted that he’s not very familiar with you and your work. He only made two points.
1) He described your lawsuit against the racists at the Otaru onsen as an “unfair tactic.” At the same time, he also stated that he felt that said racists were “idiots,” and that refusing “foreigners” entry to the onsen was “stupid,” but when I asked him what he thinks you should have done instead of filing a lawsuit, he was completely unable to provide any sort of answer.
2) He claimed that your “Little Yellow Jap” protest was “racism.” I pointed out that you obviously created “Little Yellow Jap” for the express purpose of trying to help Wajin understand what it’s like to be belittled and discriminated against in the way that they were discriminating against blacks, and that I couldn’t help but feel he was deliberately ignoring this obvious purpose in the work. His argument was that even if someone punches you, punching them back is still “violence,” and thus protesting racism by creating an obviously satirical work that makes use of the very same racism still constitutes “racism.” I pointed out that there is a difference between violence and self-defense, and that it is obvious that the purpose of the protest was not to stir up anti-Wajin racist sentiment. He stood his ground despite having no meaningful rebuttal.
To be completely fair, in his defense, he agreed with many points that I made, and he’s never been discriminatory or racist towards me personally. That being said, it boils down to a repeat of the same pattern we see so often–self-censorship for fear of reprisal from historical revisionists, racists, and their ultra right-wing buddies. It seems people with the courage to stand up and speak the truth, netouyo be damned, are few and far between.
— Thanks. From what you’ve written, I don’t see it as a lack of courage or self-censorship. More like he’s working backwards from a conclusion that only Wajin can criticize Wajin racism. That keeps the discussion of Japan’s racism “within the family”. And if said Wajin refuses to criticize, oh well, that’s his choice. And for good measure, we’ll enforce that choice on Non-Wajin too.
Anyway, clearly he’s done little research on my work beyond reading the Japanese version of the Wikipedia page on me. I might suggest he read my book “Japanese Only” in Japanese, but he probably won’t. After so many experiences he’s clearly comfortable with his world view, and won’t have the likes of us challenging it.
72hours pcr test is a bit tight for Long haul flight includes transient flight. Why JP citizen no need to provide PCR test O
I know an American who missed her father’s funeral last month but a British man who went to England in August. How was that possible? Is it just up to immigration at Narita?
The UK has a “safe list” for certain countries, so if Japan was on the list, he could have entered the UK without quarantining. I presume you mean he was then allowed back to Japan? Must be a reciprocal agreement between certain countries.
also, i know a Japanese bank exec allowed in to Europe as an “essential worker”, or specialist. he is the new CEO his bank applied for the speical visa on his behalf.
He still had to do two weeks quarantine though.
It’s worth noting that the Japanese health insurance also covers certain unexpected medical expenses while overseas.
It works like this, you pay the full amount upfront to the foreign medical institution and when you go back to Japan you can apply for reimbursement within two years.
I’m not sure if the 72-hour COVID test is covered, if you stay overseas for a long time and you need to take one before that, it could be.
Check with your local City Hall, but if you do end up getting infected and need to stay at the hospital your J health insurance should be able to cover the 60-or-so percent part of it.
This is all too much for me. Feels like my PR is as worthless and on the same level as a tourist visa. I have been here for 30 years and am now going to get my Japanese passport so I can’t be treated as a tourist any longer.
Maybe this is all about. Produce second class citizens ( Otaru Onsen case or a foreigner citizen stopped by Police detained for not carrying zaryu card and then realized and apologized etc. )
The positive aspect:
free to move as you like
no more being fingerprinted each time
case like these days
and who knows next all foreigners will be required to show they are vaccinated before come to Japan incl. tourists. Even though other countries may not make vaccination compulsory, beautiful Japan will make people get a shot of something that is undeveloped and prosperity researched.
I wouldn’t become a JP citizen if I were you. You’ll still be treated as an outsider – even with a JP passport. Glad I don’t have one.
Had enough of this country.and can’t wait to leave.
I became a citizen and I am not regretting my decision at all. Quite the opposite, to me, I felt that one of the benefits of having citizenship is being able to talk more freely about politics and prejudice in the country without being pointed as “kankei nai”. Also, at least in my case, I am being treated as equal by all my friends and coworkers. But as I don`t have an Asian face, every time I have to introduce myself to a new person, I have to kind of explain that I am Japanese (maybe that`s what you meant by being treated as a foreigner)…. but I think that even that part will get rarer, as more people naturalize in the country.
Hope things get better to you in Japan and/or in your other home.
So, what is now my 5 years re-entry in the passport for?
Yes, this policy is clearly discriminatory.
However I will say this.
A young lady I know who is a Japanese citizen and was visited Germany for a couple of weeks was required to take a the PCR test prior to re-entering Japan and actually had her approval delayed requiring her to reschedule her flight home.
So, it seems this particular requirement is being applied to citizens too.
It’s not. It might be the airlines that require this. I picked up my confirmation letter from the Embassy. My Japanese wife was with me. However only I was asked to schedule PCR 72h before flight, not before the date I land in Japan. On the J Embassy website they write the following using text in red “Japanese Citizens are not required to take PCR test prior to return to Japan”. Then we checked the Airlines website. They write that all they need is sign a paper that you don’t have any symptoms. However me, must show all the papers required by J Gov. I still call discrimination. My wife may say I’m fine as other Japanese. Anyway airlines are not allowed bring more than 50 people. There are only 5 staff at Narita who test people.
Well, NJ Olympians will be exempt from these entry restrictions (what about coaches, dieticians, other team members, journalists, and millions of spectators?), so the implicit message is that these restrictions will be in place at least until summer 2021.
„They will be tested again upon entering Japan, and will have their movements monitored and restricted after arrival. […] Athletes will be able to practice or compete in the 14-day quarantine period after arrival, but their movements will be limited to accommodations and venues specific to training and competing in their specific sports, in accordance with travel plans submitted to authorities in advance.“
Am I the only one who fears a distortion of competition? Because to me this looks like foreign athletes will only be able to train at facilities which are approved by the Japanese government, while Japanese athletes will be able to train and go wherever they want to. Maybe I‘m a bit paranoid, but what if the Japanese government provides foreign athletes with bad facilities, while Japanese athletes get the good ones, because they can chose their own facilities and don‘t have to rely on the government for approval. Limiting the movement of foreign athletes and monitoring them 24/7 is also going to impact them negatively. It looks like Japanese athletes will have an advantage if this plan should be implemented. And yes, what happens to coaches, medical staff, sponsors, IOC members etc.? What a joke all of this is. Japan is going „full China“ with this kind of constantly monitoring foreigners. Seriously, if they hate us so much, why do they keep bidding for events like the Olympics, or the football (or soccer if you prefer the American term) and Rugby World Cup? Every time such events take place in Japan, foreign residents have to suffer because racial profiling by police skyrockets. And now due to corona, things are even worse. I really hope that some athletes just boycott these Olympics. These restrictions placed on foreign athletes just aren‘t fair.
Here’s a simple solution for the Japanese Government for people with a legal right to return home.
– Test people upon arrival and request that they self isolate for up to 14 days to be safe.
No need for any complex bans or hoop jumping. Plenty of countries have asked citizens to self isolate when returning from a Coronavirus hotspot.
I would imagine many folk have friends or family who can drop off groceries so its not a huge inconvience for most.
These hoops are only in place because the people who placed them have a dislike of gaijin. Lets be honest here. Plenty of countries have handled citizens returning home without any of this nonsense.
Japan wants to supplant HK as ‘Asia’s financial hub’ by poaching foreigners and foreign investment from HK following the implementation of the ‘security law’.
But Japan is failing. Ranking 4th (down from 3 last year) whilst HK moves UP to 5th.
Of course, this is all blamed on last week’s crash of the Tokyo Stock Exchange software (I’m pretty sure the people who make these rankings didn’t just throw them together last weekend), rather than Japan genuinely being less attractive to NJ talent and investment than it was a year ago…
When you have a society that is in denial about its institutional racism (no re-entry for NJ residents), I guess there must be a lot of head scratching about the ‘cause’.
Lucky the TSE outage gave them an excuse, otherwise they’d have to start finding conspiracies to explain how the ranking is biased against them…or something. How dare NJ not appreciate Japan!
How dare NJ not appreciate Japan! Indeed, Japan is a leader in this field…why are you laughing? shut up! shut up UN!
Japan is never mentioned by those seeking to leave Hong Kong; its either Singapore- HK’s long term “rival”, Taiwan due to proximity and Chinese language, UK because of the new BNO passport upgrades, and others for various lifestyle choices.
Even VPs of certain Japanese banks I know, who work overseas ironically, will include Tokyo in the “top five financial cities” but even they put it as a distant fifth, and wax surprisingly unprofessionally about its “safe” infrastructure (they mean no demonstrations or tear gas, not earthquakes or nuclear meltdowns etc), and cannot or will not elaborate further when I probe them for specific financial laws or advantages etc.
Probably because there are none. Just nice sushi, four seasons etc. Its gobsmacking how professional and detailed their presentations are on OTHER COUNTRIES’ financial advantages but when it comes to JAPAN, it’s a trigger word for cliches and PR stereotypes. And those cliches are all the positive ones. Sadly when I think of Tokyo/Japan these days I first think of earthquakes and food safety from Tohoku.
I ll end with a song: “Maybe its because I’m a Tokyoite, that I love Tokyo so….”
btw about that study, not disagreeing so much but take it with a pinch of salt. I mean, Shanghai 3rd place? Its a communist dicktatorship, said one of the commentators. Based on last year’s figures, said others, as Chinese cities took five of the top ten spots for Fintech.
For Fintech, not for anything else. No Chinese city operates to a global financial standard of compliance which is why a lot of them are getting kicked off the NY stock exchange and have to make do with HK where they can manipulate the economy, like buying stock they were ordered to buy by the Govt of a certain bullish bear friend of Christopher Robin, so it looks like HK is is high risk for that and other reasons.
So, it is hard to draw any conclusions except HK is still OK for business, Tokyo less so, and the top two cities are undoubtedly the top two.
We will see how it is next year…..
UK IOC member allowed to fly into Japan to stand on track in the rain and make an announcement he could have done by zoom/fax (this is Japan after all).
NJ residents haven’t been allowed back in after attending family funerals!
Did he PCR test and 14 day quarantine?